modern STEM education has created an army of naive computer scientists that know how to apply processes to data but are completely oblivious to the philosophical implications and criticisms of their work
Hmm, it's almost like the corporations planned this.... 🤔
@dankwraith i think about this quite a bit
@patterfloof @esvrld @dankwraith yes, one of the reasons I love it is that it captures so well how the tech "muggles" misunderstand the "magic" of technology (this is not a dig, rather something we need to be aware of and careful with)
The other reason is that the full quote explains that the askers were politicians (from both the upper and lower houses), which is really just *chef kiss*
@dankwraith it's amazing that this lesson wasn't heeded with an intense sense of urgency in response to like, the manhattan project.
@operand @hirojin @dankwraith in my eng curriculum we had a required "ethics in engineering" class, but it was mostly about corporate codes of conduct, how to deal with client gifts, what counted as backroom dealing etc, nothing about actual ethics. Mostly about decoding legalese and doing the minimum legally required of you.
@Jewbacchus my junior year "thinking & writing for CS students" class went deep into the Therac-25 and a couple similar incidents, but I got the impression that this was as much driven by the individual professor as by any standard curriculum. and sadly a lot of the undergrads were Not Grokking It.
@operand @hirojin @dankwraith
@Jewbacchus @operand @dankwraith ya know what?
i just realised that computer science has had its Manhattan Project a few years before the Manhattan Project:
and we've learned nothing from it
@dankwraith I’d go a bit further and say “willfully ignorant of nearly implications of their work beyond how it makes money” but I’m probably jaded.
Computer guy: "If we know all the vectors of all the particles since -"
Physicist: "That won't work."
Computer guy: "But if the Universe really is a simulation -"
Physicist: "No. Go on, try it... It won't work."
Computer guy: "LOL, just watch me you arrogant ivory tower fuck"
@dankwraith If there are ethics courses involved, they're probably lumped under Topics in X, rather than any course devoted to it
@trebach @dankwraith I don't trust universities to actually do a good job teaching ethics though. The real ethics i learned was outside the required ethics courses i took. Most of the ethics courses was twisting themselves to justify domination when a corporation or a state does it and to justify punishment for disobedience.
@dankwraith being in college right now i have a feeling the evil comes at least in part from elsewhere
@dankwraith corporations brainwashing and providing monetary pathways, plus people that get into the field cause they heard they can make $$$ and have 0 empathy
@dankwraith looking at scholarships to university for my oldest son. Everything is STEM. Philosophy, ethics, law, politics, social work? Nope. Everyone wants to be Silicon Valley. We need more art and more thought. Not more algorithms.
@dankwraith the fact my workplace has a toys section labeled "stem" really is an indicatior of how parents want to train their kids to think that's legitimately the only way to *be* in life, it's almost surreal cause the slow morph of artistic toys into "(thing) lab" has bent my brain
@dankwraith okay that came off as tangential but I think "stem good art and social studies bad" is a brain poison in it's in right yeah
@dankwraith I'm a civil engineer and I feel like we're the one weird atavism because engineering ethics are still a pretty big part of the curriculum, I had one standalone ethics class and two or three others where we spent a few weeks on famous engineering failures or things like IBM's relationship to Nazi Germany
@jimpjorps if i become a teacher one day i am going to elbow drop everyone in the department repeatedly until they let me teach an ethics course
@dankwraith ...fuck. I just realized that's not accidental. Fuck.
@MadestMadness @dankwraith much of the recent surge in STEM funding is a deliberate effort from the US DoD and private defense contractors to increase the pool of qualified applicants, which increases competition among applicants, which will allow employers to offer lower salaries.
the people with the money have the power and they are definitely shaping the curriculums.
the most ethics training i got was a single guest speaker in second year of undergrad.
@dankwraith I don't speak computer but you mean when AIs do a racism right
@dankwraith ngl I'd fucking LOVE it if I were able to get my masters/doctorate in philosophy then go on to teach computer ethics at a university.
@dankwraith every school should have a mandatory Ethics class in the track for their CompSci major
@jacethechicken @dankwraith seriously. i went to a very liberal MPA program but the one thing I loved about it was how much it emphasized ethical training, education, and debate. like, just teaching people the language to consider this stuff and opportunities to debate it is such an oppportunity for growth and not being myopic
@dankwraith Speaking as a member of the previous generation, old-school now-called-STEM education also created an army (albeit smaller) of computer scientists who were totally oblivious to the philosophical implications & criticisms of their work.
That'd be the folks teaching the current crop.
@dankwraith I remember the educational controversy visible to laypeople in the mid- to late-80s was the danger of dropping/reducing liberal arts requirements for science degrees.
Clearly the removal side won. I wonder if the people who advocated for that side are satisfied with the results.
@dankwraith I'm pretty sure this was the objective .. you don't want, if you're a major government or corporation, unpredictable (principled) people in roles where they actually possess power (knowledge) hence those have to be trained to be naive (mechanistic) in applying their abilities. Exactly the opposite of a decent society.
@dankwraith this applies to every branch of modern education and I hate it
monads.online is a community for goth nerds, aka people who are interested in the intersections of math, art, programming, philosophy, and related topics. this does not include your techbro ass. we also enjoy a healthy amount of shitposting. if you are a techno-materialist, technocrat, or some flavor of capitalist, don't even bother applying. if you are interested in an account please fill out an application, detailing why you are interested in joining, what you have to bring to the community, and your prior, if any, accounts on the fediverse.